Our Natural Democracy
Natural Law #5:
The Government Performance Report Card
Be conscious of how critically important this natural law is.
The Principle:
As the ultimate employers of the state, citizens have an absolute right to a factual, independent audit of government behavior before they cast a ballot. Governments run on citizen sweat—we must have the honest facts on exactly how that government was run.
Without a verified report card, voters run the catastrophic risk of rehiring incompetent or unethical people.
The Performance Report Card
Below are the natural reasons why a performance report card is critical for citizens to possess, broken into the four essential pillars of accountability:
1. What is a Government Performance Report Card?
The foundational framework of independent, citizen-led oversight
2. What is inside the Report Card?
Quadrant A: Promised vs. Delivered (The Honesty Audit)
Quadrant B: The Money Trail (The Financial Audit)
Quadrant C: Ethics & Integrity (The Character Audit)
Quadrant D: Documented Accomplishments (The Governing Perspective)
3. Expectations of citizens who pay for everything.
-
The baseline standards demanded by the paying citizens of the nation.
1. What is a Government Performance Report Card?
It is a brief, strictly factual examination of a governing party’s behavior, spending, and ethics since they took office. This is made available publicly.
-
The Purpose: Citizen voters have a profound responsibility to hire highly skilled, ethical people to manage our economy and nation. If a government has been incompetent or corrupt, that information must be delivered clearly to the employer before voting day.
-
-
The Timeline: To prevent important data from being buried, the report card must be published at the immediate start of an election campaign, updated periodically, and issued as a final summary exactly two weeks before voting ends.
2. What is inside the Report Card?
To ensure absolute fairness, the report card balances the government's claims with independent oversight. It is divided into four critical quadrants:
Quadrant A: Promised vs. Delivered (The Honesty Audit)
Quadrant B: The Money Trail (The Financial Audit)
Quadrant C: Ethics & Integrity (The Character Audit)
Quadrant D: Documented Accomplishments (The Gov. Perspective)
-
The Balanced Review: To maintain total objectivity, these accomplishments are analyzed by an independent committee. The positive results and their corresponding negatives (such as hidden costs or long-term consequences) are published simultaneously in the same space, giving the public a multi-dimensional view of the truth.
Quadrant A: Promised vs. Delivered (The Honesty Audit)
-
Did the government fulfill their campaign promises?
-
-
If they did not, they profited from a falsehood to get hired. A promise is a binding verbal contract; breaking it without an extraordinary, proven emergency should be treated as a severe ethical breach. Why should voters believe them now?
Quadrant B: The Money Trail (The Financial Audit)
-
How did they spend the taxpayers' money, and did they overspend?
-
-
What major contracts were signed, who received them, and how much did they profit?
-
-
Did family members, friends, or donors of the politicians receive any public money or contracts?
-
-
Did any contract negotiations give away Canadian real estate, resources, or businesses to foreign or private entities?
Quadrant C: Ethics & Integrity (The Character Audit)
-
Were there any official ethics violations by politicians?
-
-
Did any public servant lie to parliament or the public?
-
-
Are government programs and departments actually performing correctly? What are the ballpark salaries of top officials, and on what criteria are "performance bonuses" being handed out?
Quadrant D: Documented Accomplishments (The Governing Perspective)
-
The Government’s Claims: What does the governing party list as its major successes and positive milestones?
3. Expectations of Citizens who pay for everything.
The citizen is the employer.
We expect the best because we pay for the best.
The Report Card enforces four non-negotiable expectations that citizens naturally demand from their employees:
-
Complete Transparency: To be adequately and continuously informed of all major government actions, failures, and successes.
-
Absolute Respect: Recognition that taxpayers fund the entire infrastructure of the country and are entitled to the data.
-
Continuous Access: The right to see this report card published and broadcast widely throughout the entire election cycle.
-
Elite Ethics: An unshakeable standard that only highly skilled, completely transparent, and deeply ethical individuals are permitted to manage the Canadian state.